Thursday, June 17, 2010

Diplomacy as Metaphor

In his speech to the nation on Tuesday night, President Obama declared war on the oil leak in the Gulf of Mexico, drawing on a familiar metaphor in American culture. Presidents have declared war many times in recent history: President Johnson’s war on poverty, President Nixon’s war on cancer, and President Reagan’s war on drugs.

The trouble is, these wars—and perhaps all wars—never really work. All of the scourges listed above—poverty, cancer, and drugs—remain as strong, if not stronger, than they were when war was first declared.

I don’t blame President Obama for his use of the metaphor. In fact, I think he and his speechwriters realize the need to use this language. Because Obama is a cerebral leader who takes his time weighing options and thoughtfully arriving at conclusions, he is perceived as weak by many in our saber-rattling culture.

Nonetheless, wishing we could move to a different metaphor, I propose the word “diplomacy.” It’s true that in diplomacy you negotiate and talk to the other side, and we really can’t do either with the oil leak. But implicit in diplomacy is understanding: understanding why poverty is so prevalent, understanding what causes cancer, and understanding how drugs invade entire communities.

In much of the President’s speech, he actually drew on diplomacy rather than on war as a model for action. Appointing an independent group to determine compensation for workers and businesses in the Gulf is an act of diplomacy. Commissioning a long-term Gulf Coast Restoration Plan is an act of diplomacy. Insisting that we understand the facts about deepwater drilling and the concomitant risks to workers and the environment is an act of diplomacy. And calling on members of both parties to propose ideas to end our country’s dependence on fossil fuels is an act of diplomacy.

President Obama understands and applies diplomacy more than he gets credit for. Or perhaps it’s that diplomacy is held in low esteem. In any case, don’t let the war metaphor fool you; it’s required shorthand that I hope will become obsolete someday.

Monday, June 14, 2010

Lessons from the Scripps Spelling Bee

Watching the finals of the Scripps Spelling Bee earlier this month was frustrating—not because the contest was poorly run or because the competitors weren’t engaging or bright. But because the ABC commentators wouldn’t shut up.

The pronouncer would pose a word to one of the students, and we would listen blissfully (as I realized later) to the contestants ask for the word’s definition, its pronunciation, its origin, and its use in a sentence. These exchanges were fascinating, as we observed the students processing each word.

But as soon as one of the kids asked a repeat question, the commentators felt free to let loose and tell us their observations and their thoughts, making it impossible for us to hear the students. Each time this happened, the spell of the bee was broken.

Talking heads of every sort—whether in sports, news, or the bee—rob listeners of the pleasure of puzzling out something alone. Maybe we want to watch the spectacular catch at home base in silence. Maybe we want to think about what we think about the oil spill. Maybe we want to hear the origin of the word one more time.

Unfiltered experience is hard to come by these days with so much non-stop talk. A little silence now and then, with room for our own reflections and ideas, might make for more thoughtful responses. By minimizing the role of knee-jerk talking heads, we could create a less predictable, less polarized society with a more informed populace.

The result? A new and improved C-O-M-M-O-N-W-E-A-L.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

A Dog's Life: Serenity


I asked my family to look at this picture of Sundance and give me adjectives that came to mind. Here’s what they said:

Peaceful
Cozy
Heavenly
Serene
Fluffy
Trusting
Adorable
Plush
Secure

These say it all, I think, the hallmarks of a good life. Not just for dogs, but for all of us.

Monday, June 7, 2010

The Birds of the Gulf

Of all the images and information coming from the oil spill, the ones that sadden me the most are the pictures of oil-laden birds struggling to survive. More than the loss of livelihood, of income, or tourism, I feel saddest about the birds.

Evidently others do, too. MoveOn.org sent to its membership one of the most upsetting pictures to surface so far of a bird in Louisiana. With the subject line “Heartbreaking,” the email called on members to protest America’s dependence on oil. MoveOn could have sent a video of angry, frustrated Gulf residents or pictures of the oil plume itself, but instead its organizers chose the bird.

And what about the deaths of the 11 rig workers, which heralded the start of the disaster? Even these losses don’t seem to supersede the loss and degradation of marine life felt so keenly by so many.

Sometimes I think our complicated, uneasy relationship with animals all goes back to Genesis, where we were given “dominion” over all of the fish and birds and every creeping creature on the earth. What did God mean by dominion? When I checked to see if the translators might have had it wrong all these years, I learned that, indeed, the Hebrew word radah means to rule, to have dominion, dominate, tread down.

So the translation is right, but maybe it’s the interpretation that’s wrong. Maybe the intention is that we are to rule benevolently, as caretakers rather than as dominators.

Or maybe it’s that God got it wrong altogether, or that the writer of Genesis misunderstood. Maybe we are to steward the earth jointly with the animals and plants that share our time here together. We don’t seem to be doing such a great job by ourselves. Maybe we need to pay more attention to the clues that the animals are giving us.

The canary in the coal mine takes on more and more meaning as we destroy more of our planet. When birds are covered in oil, they can’t live very well, if at all. The message is this: neither can we.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

The Appeal of Silly Bandz


What a refreshing fad this latest craze is. Colored rubber bands in the shapes of trombones, stars, castles, and ice cream cones—to name a few—they’re worn on the wrist like some elaborate, ancient bracelet. One pack of 12 costs $ 3.00, so you can sport a stylish look without losing too much money. Or, as is the case at my daughter’s school, those who have share with those who don’t, so everybody has at least a few. Silly Bandz elicit generosity where it’s sometimes hard to come by.

They also appeal to girls and boys alike. After years of resisting products marketed separately to each gender—brown and violent action figures for boys and pink and gentle dolls for girls—we can finally buy something that obliterates gender. Silly Bandz let kids be kids, rather than forcing boys to be boys and girls to be girls.

Perhaps the most fun of all, they are traded each day on an open market, housed on the playground or school bus. Trade a dragon for a duck. Trade a mermaid for a minotaur. Trade two figures for a phoenix, the most desired Silly Band of all, or hold out for an IPod. Each day brings something new.

Silly Bandz: simple fun in the midst of complicated times.

Monday, May 31, 2010

Belated Thoughts on J D Salinger

When J. D. Salinger died in January, we heard--ad nauseum, it seemed--both about the author's failure to publish beyond his early works and his subsequent life as a recluse. These parts of Salinger's biography were portayed as they usually are, with dismay and with a sense of failure.

After rereading this spring The Catcher in the Rye, Franny and Zooey, and Nine Stories, I can say that I share none of this disappointment. Salinger's work is brilliant. Holden Caulfield speaks not only to the disaffection of youth but also to the heartbreaking, thin line between mental health and mental dissolution. And if you haven't read the short story "For Esmé--With Love and Squalor," find it and read it immediately. The war-ravaged narrator and his meeting with the young British girl are unforgettable and, like Catcher in the Rye, transcendent of time and place.

If J. D. Salinger had more good work to publish, well, I guess it's too bad we didn't get to read it. But more often than not, we read too much from one author. Once a writer publishes one good book, it's often assumed that everything else is equally good. This is rarely the case, I've found, and results in awkward book reviews and undeserved accolades.

Perhaps Mr. Salinger got it right. Put out your best work and allow it to stand on its own merits. And maybe, just maybe, generations of readers will continue to discover you long after the book tours are over.

Thursday, May 27, 2010

Birds in Flight

In his research on a bird species called bar-tailed godwits, biologist Robert Gill discovered in 2006 amazing flight patterns that turned previous assumptions upside-down. While godwits had been thought to make several stops in Asia as they migrated from southern Alaska to New Zealand and Australia, it turns out that these large waders fly far out over the Pacific Ocean, traveling “up to 7,100 miles in nine days — the longest nonstop flight ever recorded.”

As reported in a story in this week’s New York Times, advances in technology—such as tiny and remote tracking devices—led to Professor Gill’s findings and opened up the door for similar research. Not long ago ornithologists thought that ruby-throated hummingbirds, for example, stopped in Mexico as they traveled home in the spring. We know now, though, that they “set out from the Yucatán Peninsula in the evening and arrive in the southern United States the next afternoon.”

There’s something comforting about this news from the animal kingdom, especially when our own species seems to have gone so far off track. With angry finger-pointing over the BP oil spill and violence at the Mexican border, we seem to be at war with ourselves. And not just in America. Tensions are mounting between North and South Korea, and Europe is in a tailspin over its economic woes. It’s as if the gods on Mount Olympus are looking down at the humans and wondering at the mess they’ve made of things.

I’m reminded specifically of Pandora’s Box. She seems to have opened it even wider these last several years, allowing greed and anger and hatred to flourish. Fear and mistrust abound. But Pandora offered a gift to humans as well. It was Hope that tumbled out alongside the pestilent plagues. Hope that would remain a constant comfort to the mortals below.

The bar-tailed godwits and the ruby-throated hummingbirds seem to me to carry Hope with them as they soar miles beyond our expectations. Unlike us, they’re using their god-given talents not only to survive, but to survive with grace.

We have god-given talents, too, with our minds and imagination and heart. If we use these gifts the way the birds use theirs, we just might find our way home—the home that most of us want, one devoid of hatred and injustice.